How to Lead Without Letting Instinct Lead You
Power plays in modern leadership
This article is a collaboration with Victoria. Her publication ‘Corporate Jungle’ uses animal archetypes to break down complex characters and situations in the corporate world.
Corporate power doesn’t roar. It slithers, stalks or waits. Walk into any boardroom and you can feel it before anyone speaks—the stillness before someone asserts control, the way a single interruption can redraw the hierarchy. Leadership often looks like composure on the surface, but underneath runs a jungle of instinct.
When the pressure rises, even the most rational among us revert to something older and more primal. The brain, flooded with cortisol, stops reasoning and starts reacting. The amygdala calls the shots long before strategy does. You’ll likely see lots of behaviours emerging, for example:
📢 The person who interrupts to reassert control.
🙉 The one who withdraws to preserve safety.
📝 The silent observer who takes note and waits for the right time to intervene.
These are evolutionary habits resurfacing in boardrooms, negotiations and performance reviews. However, leadership, unlike survival, isn’t about winning a single fight. It’s about sustaining trust. And that means knowing when instinct helps you lead and when it undermines you.
The Predator Within
Every leader has an inner predator. It might be subtle—a tone shift, a raised eyebrow, a silence that signals dominance. Or it might be visible—the sharp response, the public correction, the micromanaging spiral. These impulses come from the same place that once kept us alive. In a competitive environment, they still serve a purpose, but we should be careful not to mistake these instincts for our identity
Some leaders strike like snakes or spiders—patient, deliberate, moving only when advantage appears. Others hold ground like lions or cheetahs—commanding space through presence or speed. A few scorpions bide their time, stinging only when slighted. And some sharks cut through indecision—focused, fast, fearless.
For some, this is a natural gift; for others, it’s a learned behaviour, refined through years of navigating the jungle and advancing through organisational layers.
“Greatness is not a function of circumstance. Greatness, it turns out, is largely a matter of conscious choice, and discipline.” - Jim Collins
The trouble begins when the instinct becomes the default.
🐍 When the snake forgets to release the throat hold.
🦁 When the lion’s confidence dismisses hyenas circling on its territory.
🦂 When the scorpion’s defence turns into resentment.
🦚 When the peacock’s performance crowds out other voices.
🦈 When the shark, in its drive to deliver, leaves a trail of fear and loss of trust behind.
At that point, the instinct that once protected performance begins to poison it.
Regression Under Pressure
Under uncertainty, leaders often regress, and old coping patterns reappear:
The confident strategist tightens into control.
The calm listener withdraws into distance.
The decisive operator slides into dismissal.
Power amplifies this drift: the higher you climb, the less you’re challenged, and the easier it is to rationalise instinct as standard behaviour.
Understanding this is an act of self-preservation. When you can recognise your own pattern under stress, you regain choice. And choice is the purest form of leadership control there is.
A simple practice helps:
Pause. Notice the quickened pulse, clenched jaw, the urge to go first.
Channel. Ask what this instinct is protecting—reputation, your team, competence. There’s usually a valid intention beneath the reaction.
Choose. What serves this moment best? Shark precision? Lion calm? Or a peacemaker’s restraint?
This deliberate sequence reactivates the prefrontal cortex, the part of the brain responsible for empathy, planning and foresight. It’s the same neurological shift that turns a reactive meeting into a constructive one.
Over time, you will be able to identify and name your trigger zones. These are the situations that awaken your inner predator (things like tight deadlines, public critique, unprepared colleagues). Awareness will shrink their power over you when you’re least expecting the pressure.
We also recommend that you find a trusted peer who can call you out gently when your instincts hijack your judgment. Ideally, you should do this in private (as opposed to during meetings or live conversations), so you can digest the feedback without spiralling into defence mode.
Over time, these small acts of awareness will rewire not only your responses but also the tone of the teams around you.
A Moment in The Boardroom
Quarterly results come in below target, and the air tightens. The CEO feels it—the pulse quickening, the urge to interrogate, to reassert control. The shark is waking.
They pause instead. “Let’s not rush to conclusions,” they say, steadying the tone. On the whiteboard, they draw three columns: Process, People, External factors. “Where did the friction start?”
Voices that were tense a moment ago begin to share detail. Finance points to a bottleneck. Operations adds context. The energy shifts from defence to problem-solving.
By noticing the instinct and choosing a different move, the leader turns a confrontation into collaboration. The calm comes from steering the innate instinct where it can have the best impact.
The Strength of Stillness
The paradox of modern leadership is that the more chaotic the environment becomes, the more people look for calm. And leadership isn’t the absence of the predator or pretending we are immune to instinct. It’s mastery over it when it emerges. We must learn to pause long enough to let wisdom outrun our reactions.
The next time tension sharpens your tone or tightens your chest, pause before reacting. Take three breaths and think before you speak:
Which part of me just woke up?
Is this feeling relevant to the situation or will it cause more harm?
Is my instinctive response how I want my leadership to be remembered?
Share this article with a trusted peer and give them permission to name your animal—privately.
I’m Andrea, a management consultant with over a decade of experience across industry and academia. I work with commercial, non-profit, academic and government organisations worldwide, helping them capture meaningful insights through mixed methods research.
I write about practical frameworks to help you discover what others miss. My main goal is to translate complex concepts into techniques that readers can use immediately.
 | A guest post by
|
Mastering one’s emotions is the way forward! Also having the knowledge and understanding of which part of oneself can be easily preyed is an important strategy.
Thank you for this great read and the tips: pause, channel and choose.